What Is Wrong With Contemplative Prayer

What Is Wrong With Contemplative Prayer

Contemplative prayer stands as a revered practice, inviting individuals into the sacred realm of inner contemplation and spiritual communion. It beckons seekers to delve beyond the superficial layers of existence, guiding them toward a profound connection with the divine. Rooted in the depths of silence and introspection, this practice has long intrigued spiritual enthusiasts, offering a path to transcendence.


However, amidst its mystique and allure, what is wrong with contemplative prayer has attracted scrutiny and discourse, with voices pondering its nuances and potential pitfalls. Beyond its veil of tranquility lies a landscape ripe with queries, discussions, and concerns regarding its appropriateness, efficacy, and impact on individuals’ lives.

Table of Contents


What Is Wrong With Contemplative Prayer

Before looking into the concerns, it is important to understand the nature of contemplative prayer. Contemplative prayer is a method of prayer that aims to go beyond thoughts, words, and concepts, and instead focuses on experiencing a direct encounter with the divine presence. It often involves the repetition of a sacred word or phrase and the cultivation of inner silence and stillness.

1. Emphasis on Eastern Mystical Traditions

Contemplative prayer draws inspiration from various mystical traditions, particularly those found in Eastern religions such as Buddhism and Hinduism. Some critics argue that this emphasis on Eastern practices may lead to a dilution or syncretism of Christian theology and spirituality.

2. Lack of Scriptural Foundation

Another concern raised by critics is the perceived lack of a Scriptural foundation for contemplative prayer. They argue that the practice places less emphasis on studying and meditating on the teachings of the Bible, which is considered central to Christian faith and spirituality.

Potential Issues with Contemplative Prayer

While contemplative prayer can be a deeply meaningful experience for many individuals, there are several potential issues that have been raised by its critics. It is important to consider these concerns when engaging in or evaluating this practice.


1. Risk of Spiritual Deception

One of the central concerns associated with contemplative prayer revolves around the potential for spiritual deception. Detractors contend that the profound state of deep silence and stillness often sought in contemplative practices may render individuals susceptible to deceptive spiritual influences or experiences that may not align with traditional Christian teachings. The worry is that, in the pursuit of a heightened spiritual connection, individuals engaged in contemplative prayer might inadvertently open themselves up to misleading or even counterfeit spiritual encounters.

Critics argue that the subjective and highly personal nature of contemplative experiences makes it challenging to discern between genuinely divine revelations and potentially misleading influences. This concern emphasizes the importance of discernment and theological grounding to ensure that contemplative practices align with orthodox Christian beliefs and do not inadvertently lead practitioners down paths that deviate from the core tenets of their faith. Consequently, proponents of contemplative prayer often stress the necessity of proper guidance, sound theological education, and a discerning approach to minimize the risk of spiritual deception.

2. Detachment from Community and Tradition

Contemplative prayer is often practiced in solitude and silence, which can lead to a sense of detachment from the community and the traditions of the faith. Critics argue that this isolation may hinder the development of a robust and balanced spiritual life that is rooted in the communal aspects of worship, fellowship, and accountability.


3. Lack of Discernment and Guidance

Engaging in contemplative prayer without proper discernment and guidance can be problematic. Critics suggest that without the guidance of experienced spiritual mentors or directors, individuals may be more susceptible to misinterpreting their experiences or straying into unorthodox or potentially harmful spiritual practices.

Addressing the Concerns

Amidst the discussions surrounding contemplative prayer, it is essential to acknowledge and engage with the valid concerns that have been raised. Critics often express reservations about the potential risks associated with contemplative practices, citing concerns related to doctrinal integrity, spiritual experiences, and the potential for syncretism. However, proponents of contemplative prayer advocate for a nuanced and discerning approach to the practice, emphasizing that these concerns can be effectively addressed.

Additionally, proponents emphasize the potential benefits of contemplative prayer when approached with a sincere heart and a desire for deeper intimacy with the divine. They argue that, when practiced with a genuine seeking of God’s presence, contemplative prayer can foster spiritual growth, inner transformation, and a heightened awareness of the sacred. The focus is on cultivating a personal relationship with God rather than on pursuing mystical experiences divorced from one’s faith tradition.

In essence, the advocacy for contemplative prayer involves a call for a balanced and informed approach. While recognizing the valid concerns that surround this practice, proponents encourage believers to engage in contemplative prayer with a foundation of robust doctrinal understanding, a discerning spirit, and a sincere intention to draw closer to God within the framework of their faith. This approach seeks to address concerns while affirming the potential for contemplative practices to deepen one’s spiritual journey in a manner that aligns with and enhances their religious convictions.

1. Grounding in Scriptural Teachings

Advocates of contemplative prayer emphasize the importance of grounding the practice in the teachings of the Bible. By integrating Scripture into the contemplative experience, individuals can ensure that their encounters with the divine align with Christian principles and values.

2. Spiritual Guidance and Accountability

Seeking spiritual guidance and accountability from trusted mentors or directors can help navigate the potential pitfalls of contemplative prayer. These individuals can provide guidance, discernment, and a framework for interpreting and integrating the contemplative experiences into one’s spiritual journey.


In the labyrinth of spirituality, contemplative prayer emerges as a beckoning pathway, offering seekers a transcendent journey inward. Yet, within its tranquil embrace lie intricacies demanding caution and introspection.

Navigating the realm of contemplative prayer requires a delicate dance between spiritual depth and practical engagement, emphasizing the need for moderation and guidance. Balancing its potential pitfalls ensures a more holistic and enriching spiritual odyssey.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Is contemplative prayer only practiced by Christians?

No, contemplative prayer is practiced by individuals of various religious and spiritual traditions, although the specific techniques and approaches may vary.

2. Can contemplative prayer be harmful?

Contemplative prayer itself is not inherently harmful, but engaging in the practice without discernment or proper guidance can potentially lead to spiritual confusion or deviation from faith. It is important to approach contemplative prayer with caution and seek appropriate guidance.

3. Is contemplative prayer a form of meditation?

Contemplative prayer shares similarities with certain forms of meditation, as both involve entering into a state of deep stillness and silence. However, contemplative prayer is specifically focused on connecting with the divine presence, while meditation can have various objectives and may not necessarily involve a religious or spiritual dimension.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like